Will capping the prices of knee implants really help patients?

|
Friday, August 18, 2017
will capping the prices of knee implants really help patients?
Image for representation purpose only

After capping the price of coronary stents, the government has now capped the cost of knee implants.
 
The most commonly used knee implant-- made of cobalt chromium-- in India would now cost patients Rs 54,740 instead of 1.5 lakh earlier. In fact,  some hospitals used to charge as much as Rs 4.5 lakh for it.
 
Total knee implant made of other metals such as titanium and oxidized zirconium is now priced at Rs 76,600, almost 69 per cent lower than its original average MRP. 
 
The step will bring a lot of relief to patients who could not afford an implant and had no choice but to live with the crippling pain.
 
The current market size of the Orthopedic implant in India is around Rs 2400 crores and is expected to grow at 20 per cent for next three years. The orthopedic implants can be divided into four major categories: implants used in trauma, spine injuries, knee and hip. While Indian companies mostly manufacture trauma and spine implants, multinational companies dominate the knee and hip implants market. 
 
Eighty-five percent of the knee and hip implants used in India are manufactured by multinational companies. Knee procedures are more common in the country because of various lifestyle and hereditary factors. Squatting and sitting on the floors are integral to Indian lifestyle, which puts excessive pressure on the knee joints.
 
"Around 1.9 lakh knee implant surgeries are conducted in the country every year, while an estimated 4 lakh people need implants. Around two lakh people don't go for the surgery because they can't afford it," says Rajiv Chabbra, president, Orthopedic Implants Manufacturers Association (OIMA).
 
The decision, many feel  will also give a boost to Indian manufacturers, who have only 5-7 per cent market share. " We feel that that the prices set by the government suit both manufacturers and as well as distributors. It will also encourage us to do more research in this sector," says Vivek Sharma, CEO, Sharma Orthopedic pvt ltd.
 
"If an implant can be performed for at Rs 65,000 in Tamil Nadu under a government scheme called Arogyashri, why is it not possible elsewhere, " asks Chabbra. "The only difficulty we see is how hospitals are going to implement it at such a short notice," he says.
 
Union minister of chemical and fertilizers, Ananth Kumar says that that the move to regulate knee implant prices would save around Rs 1,500 crore for the patients.
 
But experts say the move will benefit patients only if the government ensures the reduction in the total cost of procedure that includes many ‘extra costs’ charged by hospitals. 

 
The new rates for knee implants 
 
1. Primary Knee replacement (Cobalt, Cromium)
With Patella: 54, 720
Without Patella: 50, 630
 
2. Primary Knee replacement (Titanium, Oxidized zirconium Coated )
 With Patella: 76, 660
Without Patella: 72, 570 
 
3. Revison Knee (any Material)
With Patella: 113, 950
Without Patella: 109, 860

 
 

Comment

I think this price is normal price it cut only doctors commission, Dr. Will adjust in other way.

Kaushik Patel    2017/08/18 09:55:28

Verry good step taken by gov it will help our citizens aswel India manufachur

Dayanand Sharma    2017/08/18 02:45:43

Performing a liver transplant on this three-month-old baby was a deeply gratifying moment in my career 

Surgery has, and continues to fascinate me. I chose a surgical residency due to its immediacy- one can exercise a certain set of skills and be privy to seeing instant resu....

Ophthalmologists can make an early diagnosis of many serious diseases through eye examination: Dr Amod Gupta

 The eye examination is often neglected by primary care physicians. But the fact is eyes act as a diagnostic window, revealing signs of systemic disease before symptoms ap....

This handy, wireless pocket-sized ECG machine can revolutionise cardiac care 

This engineer couple, Neha and Rahul, took up the challenge to make a leadless, portable ECG device themselves....

University of Dundee Research aims to solve Neuropathic Pain mysteries

Researchers at the University of Dundee seek to understand the mechanisms driving neuropathic pain and its intensity in patients, which affects appr....

 

The Research International Conference on Medical, Medicine and Health Science will be held in New Delhi, India on March 25, 2024....